Westminster Scotland Wales London Northern Ireland European Union Local
ePolitix.com

 
[ Advanced Search ]

Login | Contact | Terms | Accessibility

Dobson launches assault on Labour 'elitism'

Tony Blair's government is adopting "elitist" policies for health and education, Frank Dobson has claimed.

The former health secretary has launched a wide ranging attack on plans to promote diversity among schools and hospitals.

In an article for the Observer, Dobson also took an apparent swipe at Andrew Adonis - the former Oxford don who now heads Number 10's policy unit and whose support for university top-up fees is thought to have contributed to Estelle Morris's resignation.

"Unfortunately, among the shadowy ranks of the government's advisers are beneficiaries of an elitist education, whose policy initiatives perpetuate and exacerbate the inequalities of the English education system," he wrote.

In a wide ranging critique of the "elitism" at the heart of key Labour policies, the former Cabinet minister said the government should be trying to repeat the success of its polices for primary education, where the gap between the best and worst performing schools is narrowing.

He admitted that the government has ploughed extra resources into the comprehensive sector.

"But while the more successful schools are being helped to develop yet further and faster with extra money teachers, power, prestige and partial selection, how can the weaker ones ever catch up?"

Turning to higher education, Dobson said the idea of top-up fees would be "another elitist solution".

"Badly-off students are already under-represented in the more prestigious institutions. Top-up fees are likely to make matters worse," he argued.

But his criticisms were dismissed by the higher education minister, Margaret Hodge. "Sameness is not actually the answer to equality of opportunity," she said.

"We will ensure that the universities are properly funded and that there's an appropriate balance between the contribution from individuals, their families and the state," Hodge told Sky News' Sunday with Adam Boulton programme.

Dobson went on to warn that "now the elitists have started shaping the government's health policies".

He labelled plans to create foundation hospitals - which would be given extra freedoms in return for performing well - as "profoundly elitist".

He said that a "small elite" of just 12 hospitals at the outset will "be singled out for special privileges and extra resources".

"The elitists justify giving advantages to foundation hospitals on the grounds of 'earned autonomy'. In other words, the hospitals deserve it.

"But this displays an obsession with institutions rather than the people they are there to serve. Whatever the hospitals deserve, no patients deserve to see their local hospital put at a disadvantage."

Dobson also warned that the policies could have damaging electoral consequences for the government.

"No Labour MP fought the last election on a promise of a two-tier system with 12 hospitals in the top tier.

"At the next election, only a dozen Labour MPs will be able to boast their hospitals are in the top tier. The rest will have to explain why theirs are not," he wrote.

Published: Sun, 3 Nov 2002 01:00:00 GMT+00

» STAKEHOLDER LINKS

4Children
ASDAN - About ASDAN
Association of Teachers and Lecturers - Newsroom
Basic Skills Agency - Our Work
BNTL
British Sports Trust - The Awards
BUPA - ePolitix Consultations
Business Services Association - Welcome
Campaigning for Mainstream Universities - Welcome
Carers UK - Research & Good Practice
Chartered Institute of Marketing
CLIC - Welcome
Construction Products Association
Council of Heads of Medical Schools' - Council of Heads of Medical Schools
Council of Mortgage Lenders
Depression Alliance - ePolitix Consultations
Engineering and Technology Board - Consultations
English Heritage
Finance & Leasing Association
Forum of Private Business
General Medical Council - Welcome
General Social Care Council - Education & training
General Teaching Council
Health Professions Council - About the Health Professions Council
Homeless Link
IEE
Institute of Directors
Institute of Education, University of London
Institute of Financial Services
Insulin Dependent Diabetes Trust
Joseph Rowntree Foundation
Learning and Skills Council - Welcome
Leonard Cheshire
Local Government Information Unit
London Institute - Welcome
Medical Research Council
NASUWT - Welcome
National Deaf Childrens Society - Education
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
National Union of Teachers
NESTA
NHS Confederation
NMC
Open University - Welcome
Princes Trust
Professional Association of Teachers - PAT News
Royal College of Physicians
SANE - ePolitix Consultations
SCOP - About HE colleges
Secondary Heads Association - Media
Stroke Association - Agenda For Change
Universities Council for the Education of Teachers - ePolitix Consultations
Which?