'No surprise' over collapse of MP allowance talks

23rd April 2009

The chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life has said that he is "not surprised" that party leaders have failed to reach agreement on reform of MPs' expenses.

Sir Christopher Kelly told the BBC that there was no "unambiguously right answer" on allowances for MPs.

His comments came after Gordon Brown met Conservative leader David Cameron and Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg on Wednesday night in an attempt to reach agreement on the controversial issue.

However, talks ended after half an hour with no consensus reached.

Number 10 has also said that despite setting out its own plans for reform, it still wants the review launched on Thursday by Sir Christopher's committee to go ahead.

Sir Christopher denied claims that the prime minister's plans to reform MPs' expenses undermined the committee's inquiry.

"I didn't feel undermined at all because I was not at all surprised that what happened last night did happen," he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

"I am not surprised that the party leaders failed to meet agreement last night.

"These are very difficult issues and there is unlikely to be any unambiguously right answer, which is why what is needed is an independent look at it by a committee such as ours."

He said that he understood the pressure placed on the prime minister to restructure allowances.

"The tide of public fury about what has been going on over MPs' expenses is overwhelming," he said.

"I quite understand why he felt it necessary to be seen to be acting quickly."

The prime minister made clear that his proposals were interim plans, Sir Christopher said.

They are subject to any conclusions that the committee comes to, he added.

But the committee chairman also expressed doubt about whether the prime minister's proposals would actually be voted on by MPs.

"If indeed these changes are introduced, then we will have to take account of them and way them up against other alternatives," he said. "If the committee comes to the conclusion that some of the things that were introduced were wrong then we will say so."

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

Old expenses figures published

Goats 'humiliated' by Parliament

Cameron insists he is still 'in charge'

Jailed politician to challenge sentence

Four years good, five years bad



Latest news

Wolf report 'moment of truth' for skills

Many vocational courses for students improve school league table performance but do not help young people get into university or find a job, according to a government education adviser.


Cameron 'caught napping' by Libya crisis

The government has been accused of displaying a "pattern of incompetence", following its response to the crisis in Libya.


Hunt hails Britain's Oscar winners

The culture secretary has sent "warm congratulations" to the British actors and film professionals who won Oscars earlier this week.


Burstow calls for end of ageism in NHS


Wales voting in powers referendum


Aviation tax 'hampers economic growth'


Ministers 'don't get Sure Start'


A yes vote would take Wales forward


More from Dods