Ministers urged not to 'give in' to Murdoch

12th November 2009

Business minister Ian Lucas has said that illegal file sharing had a "huge impact" on the creative industries.

During Commons questions he sought to reassure MPs that any suggestion of removing internet access from individuals would be a "last resort".

Former Labour minister Tom Watson (Lab, West Bromwich East) said the sample used by the music industry to demonstrate the scale internet piracy had been "soundly ridiculed" by the BBC.

And he warned that internet service providers would suffer financially if people were cut off.

Liberal Democrat Phil Willis (Lib Dem, Harrogate and Knaresborough) said that the only way to create a truly competitive market was to allow different broadband platforms to get access to content, such as BSkyB's premium programmes.

He urged ministers not to "give in to Murdoch".

But Lucas' claim that the government benches never liked to give in to Rupert Murdoch was met with shouts of derision from opposition MPs.

"We are not in the pocket of anyone," Lucas insisted.

Mark Todd (Lab, South Derbyshire) said many rural communities were still suffering from unacceptably slow connection speeds, which were damaging both individuals and business.

"Isn’t it time take a tougher regulatory line with BT?" he asked.

Lucas agreed that it was "not acceptable" that individuals and businesses are excluded from broadband.

"It's for that reason that the government has set out a clear policy and is determined to extend broadband," he told MPs.

The exchanges in the Commons came as internet sales giant eBay published a report revealing almost half of online retailers are based in rural areas.

Responding to the report, digital Britain minister Stephen Timms said: "That's why we're ensuring business and consumers in rural areas have access to quality broadband at speeds of at least two megabit per second through our Universal Service Commitment - and also taking steps to ensure next generation networks reach over 90 per cent of the country by 2017."

Business minister Ian Lucas has said that illegal file sharing had a "huge impact" on the creative industries.

During Commons questions he sought to reassure MPs that any suggestion of removing internet access from individuals would be a "last resort".

Former Labour minister Tom Watson (Lab, West Bromwich East) said the sample used by the music industry to demonstrate the scale internet piracy had been "soundly ridiculed" by the BBC.

And he warned that internet service providers would suffer financially if people were cut off.

Liberal Democrat Phil Willis (Lib Dem, Harrogate and Knaresborough) said that the only way to create a truly competitive market was to allow different broadband platforms to get access to content, such as BSkyB's premium programmes.

He urged ministers not to "give in to Murdoch".

But Lucas' claim that the government benches never liked to give in to Rupert Murdoch was met with shouts of derision from opposition MPs.

"We are not in the pocket of anyone," Lucas insisted.

Mark Todd (Lab, South Derbyshire) said many rural communities were still suffering from unacceptably slow connection speeds, which were damaging both individuals and business.

"Isn’t it time take a tougher regulatory line with BT?" he asked.

Lucas agreed that it was "not acceptable" that individuals and businesses are excluded from broadband.

"It's for that reason that the government has set out a clear policy and is determined to extend broadband," he told MPs.

The exchanges in the Commons came as internet sales giant eBay published a report revealing almost half of online retailers are based in rural areas.

Responding to the report, digital Britain minister Stephen Timms said: "That's why we're ensuring business and consumers in rural areas have access to quality broadband at speeds of at least two megabit per second through our Universal Service Commitment - and also taking steps to ensure next generation networks reach over 90 per cent of the country by 2017."

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

Labour to consider rural policy

Lib Dems head to Sheffield

Peers experiment with online engagement

Lib Dem attacks Tories' EU allies

Cable 'quite angry' over Telegraph sting



Latest news

Commons to debate no-fly zone on Monday

MPs will be given a chance to approve military action against Gaddafi on Monday, as French jets have taken to the skies above Libya.


MPs praise Cameron's diplomacy

The prime minister has been widely praised by MPs for his leadership over the crisis in Libya.


Bill of Rights commission launched

An independent commission to investigate the case for a British Bill of Rights has been launched by the government.


People with autism lobby MPs


RAF to target Gaddafi


Coffey's maritime wrecks bill passes Commons


No elephant rules, please


MP hits out at 'shameful' building society closures


More from Dods