Lords are 'losing the moral high ground'

20th January 2011

The ongoing stand off between government and opposition peers over legislation which paves the way for a referendum on the voting system risks damaging the reputation of the upper chamber, the Commons has heard.

Commons leader Sir George Young said peers would lose the "moral high tone" should the debate in the House of Lords continue to grind on.

He said he was "concerned" about the behaviour of peers over the debate, which could see the May 5 referendum date pushed back should the bill not reach the statute book by February 16.

The Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill needs to be passed by the February date for the referendum to take place as the Electoral Commission has ruled that it needs three months to prepare for the vote.

Labour are being accused of attempting to sabotage bill, which would allow for a referendum on the voting system and cuts the number of MPs by 50.

The upper chamber rose at 3.04 am today, following the 11th day of committee stage debate, which ended five hours after the usual 10pm finishing time.

During questions on forthcoming parliamentary business, Harriet Baldwin (Con, West Worcestershire) critcised the "outrageous filibustering tactics" of Labour peers.

She asked: "Will the Leader of the House ensure that the debate on parliamentary reform in Westminster Hall is broad enough to cover the outrageous filibustering tactics of Labour Lords this week in the other place, which does not benefit from the tender ministrations of our Speaker?"

In response, Sir George said: "When I came into this House some time ago all the rough trade was down here and down the other end they had non-partisan, short, focused debates in a revising chamber.

"The rough trade now seems to have gone down the other end.

"The other place runs the risk of losing the moral high tone if its Members continue to proceed as they are."

Peers are now due return to the committee stage of the bill issue next week on Monday and Wednesday, when ministers hope it will be concluded.

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

Oldham's lessons for Labour

Labour victory in Oldham East by-election

Polls open in Oldham East and Saddleworth

Labour condemns prisoner voting

Voting system is 'broken'



Latest news

Andy Coulson resigns

Andy Coulson has resigned as Downing Street communications director, having decided that "when a spokseman needs a spokseman" it was time to quit.


Ed Balls replaces Alan Johnson

Westminster was caught off guard by Alan Johnson's resignation as shadow chancellor yesterday afternoon, a move that has prompted a fundamental realignment of power within Labour


Mental health and the Choosing Well? campaign

The choice agenda is helping to extend a key part of the NHS reforms to mental health services, says Nicky Morgan MP.


Benefit system 'mistakes' slammed


Cooper moves to home in mini-reshuffle


MPs complain again about Ipsa


Lords are 'losing the moral high ground'


National curriculum to be reviewed


More from Dods