English votes for English laws?

23rd April 2010

A giant St George's flag has been projected onto the side of the Houses of Parliament as part of a campaign for an English Parliament today, St George's Day.

Carried out by the Power2010 campaign, the stunt was designed to highlight what some see as the injustice of the 'West Lothian question'.

The pressure group says the ability of MPs from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland to vote on English matters that do not affect their constituents is a "basic failure of democracy at the heart of the UK".

Calls for the constitutional anomaly to be resolved are likely to increase if the Scottish National Party and Plaid Cymru wield increased influence in a hung parliament.

Power2010 was launched in the wake of the expenses scandal and asks people to contribute ideas on how to change the political system.

Meanwhile, Tory leader David Cameron joined London Mayor Boris for a walkabout in the City this morning to celebrate St Georges Day.

Speaking on the day the British National Party launches its manifesto, Cameron said he wanted to "reclaim" the English flag from the far-right party.

"Today we are celebrating St George's Day, and we are reclaiming St George's Day as an important day I think for good reasons," he said.

"We should be reclaiming the flag from the BNP and saying the flag belongs to the English people, all of them."

The Conservative Party has pledged to introduce new rules so that legislation referring specifically to England, or to England and Wales, can only be enacted with the consent of MPs representing constituencies in those countries.

The Liberal Democrats want to address the status of England within a federal Britain, through a Constitutional Convention set up to draft a written constitution for the UK as a whole.

Labour does not mention the issue in its manifesto, but does call for an all-party commission to "chart a course" to a written constitution.

The proposal to introduce "English votes for English laws" will be welcomed by the SNP, which will welcome further separation of English and Scottish law making.

SNP MPs already follow a self-imposed ban on voting on matters that only affect England.

The UK Independence Party, by contrast, would like to see the members of the Welsh and Scottish Parliaments replaced with Westminster MPs from the nations, meeting one week a month on devolved business and the rest of their time at Westminster.

English MPs would meet in Westminster for English-only days as an English Parliament.

The 'West Lothian question' derives its name from that constituency's MP, Tam Dalyell, who in 1977 raised the issue of Scottish MPs (of which he was one) exerting "important, and probably often decisive, effect on English politics".

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

Murdochs to appear before Commons committee

MPs to review expenses system

Ipsa system a 'great burden', say MPs

ePolitix.com: PMQs briefing

Always time to play



Latest news

Phone hacking: Parliament to sit extra day

Parliament will sit on Wednesday to give MPs another chance to question the prime minister over phone hacking, following the resignation of Metropolitan Police commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson.


Environmental impact of the Thames tunnel

Lord Berkeley questions the environmental efficiency of the proposed Thames tunnel.


Off-exchange trading 'lacks transparency'

Baroness Kramer urges the government to monitor off-exchange trading venues and determine whether they need legal or regulatory change.


Queen should pay staff 'living wage'


'Ten days that shook the world'


Peer warns over EBacc skills shortage


New standards for teachers


Plans to cut coastguards watered down


More from Dods