MPs call for end to fish discards

Bookmark and Share

13th May 2011

The government has backed calls for the European Union to end the "scandal" of forcing fishermen to throw "perfectly edible" fish back into the sea.

Fisheries minister Richard Benyon told MPs there was a "window of opportunity" to reform the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) and he hoped to see discards eradicated.

MPs approved a backbench motion, which called on the government to vote against proposed reforms of the EU Commons Fisheries Policy unless they implement an ecosystems-based approach to fisheries management, without a vote.

The fisheries minister said: "The conscience of the nation has been moved by the sight of perfectly edible, quality fish being thrown into the sea dead. An abomination in a hungry world, I'm sure everyone agrees."

People were "outraged" at the practice, he said, adding: "What if half of the lambs we slaughtered in this country had been dumped at the side of the road? There would have been riots in the streets."

Benyon told MPs: "I may not be a rabid Eurosceptic but I'm no friend of the CFP. It is not the fact that the CFP is 'common' that is the problem, it is the 'policy' that is wrong.

"Fish do not respect lines on maps. Many stocks that our fishermen exploit spend half their life in the waters of other countries."

A shared legal framework was necessary to manage fish stocks but this should be free from "unnecessary and over-detailed regulation" and stocks should be managed on a "regional or sea basin basis".

He said: "It means giving fishermen clear entitlements to fish stocks and giving them a stake in the long-term health of those stocks."

Shadow environment minister Willie Bain called for an end to the "scandal of discarded fish that has so appalled so many people in this country".

He said: "With a strong motion passed by this House today, concerted action by the EU Commission and member state governments, we can turn intentions into deeds worthy of the cause raised in the Fish Fight campaign.

"Let us work for an ecosystems approach to fisheries, let us introduce a regionalised structure for the CFP, let us establish long-term catch quotas, let us provide incentives for new nets and new technologies."

Proposing the motion, Tory Zac Goldsmith said was difficult to know how many fish were discarded, but EU estimates pointed to towards the figure being around 40 to 60 per cent of the total catch.

The Richmond Park MP called it "grossly unfair" that fisherman got the blame for those figures, as discards were "inevitable and unavoidable consequence of decisions imposed on them by politicians."

Goldsmith called on the government to "act now" to end the "scandal" of fish discards, calling on ministers to protect UK small fishing vessels from the "onslaught" of industrial foreign trawlers.

He suggested replacing landing quotas with catch quotas, so fish that would otherwise be discarded had to be landed.

Concluding, the fisheries minister welcomed the motion, however, he said it did not fully reflect the scope of the government ambition for CFP reform.

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

ePolitix election focus: energy and environment

Action urged to protect fishing industry

Coastal protection plan launched

Scotland plans EU fisheries opt out

MPs attack 'cod wars' compensation scheme



Latest news

Clegg's Lords reform plans unveiled

Nick Clegg has unveiled plans for an 80 per cent elected House of Lords with the first elections pencilled in for 2015.


Education minister borrows Commons speech from Wikipedia

Further education minister John Hayes appears to have lifted a major section of a speech delivered in the House of Commons from Wikipedia.


PM confident over bank lending

The prime minister has told the Commons liaison committee that he is confident the deal on lending with the banks will yield results.


Aid commitment 'will happen'


Clarke: Parliament 'could pass privacy law'


Boris: Olympics ticket system is 'peculiar'


Boris and the art of the faux-naif


Government calls on Mary Portas to revive high street


More from Dods