Westminster Scotland Wales London Northern Ireland European Union Local
ePolitix.com

 
[ Advanced Search ]

Login | Contact | Terms | Accessibility

Asylum targets 'must be realistic'
Committee chairman Chris Mullin

Official targets for removing asylum seekers should be more realistic, senior MPs have told the government in a stark report.

A report into the controversial issue of removing asylum seekers who have failed to prove their case warned that targets set by the Home Office must be "rational and achievable".

Members of the home affairs select committee also concluded that the processes for deporting economic migrants who have made false claims is "a great deal more complicated" than most people realise.

The committee also warns that Britain is increasingly unable to cope with the number of asylum seekers and suggests that recent increases in numbers is unsustainable.

Asylum groups have welcomed the report and called on the government to act upon it immediately. Ministers have also said the investigation was of benefit to the debate on asylum, but insisted they are already tackling the problems identified.

The only way to restore credibility to the system is in making the applications process more simple, committee chairman Chris Mullin said.

Home secretary David Blunkett was this year forced to admit that the government had failed to deal with the crisis and that the number of asylum seekers had topped 100,000 for the first time.

Although improvements have been made, the MPs warned that setting targets - such as the 30,000 annual removals benchmark later abandoned by the Home Office - only managed to demoralise staff.

The committee suggested offering destitute asylum seekers whose application has failed a small resettlement grant.

"We want to see applications for asylum processed as quickly, efficiently and fairly as possible and the removal of those whose applications fail," Mullin said.

The report says the increase in the number of asylum seekers in the UK - from 4223 in 1982 to 110,700 in 2002 - is "unacceptable".

But against a backdrop of media hysteria and the hardline taken by ministers hoping to halt the crisis, Mullin stressed the need to act with humanity.

"We should never lose sight of the fact that, whether we are dealing with genuine asylum seekers or economic migrants, we are dealing with human beings, not numbers and they should be treated accordingly," he said.

Beverley Hughes, the Home Office minister charged with tackling the problems, welcomed the report and promised that her department would consider it carefully.

"I am pleased that the committee has recognised the importance of the removal of those with no right to be here to an effective immigration policy, and the appropriate use of detention to support that," she said.

"I am also pleased that the committee acknowledges that there are no 'simple, overnight solutions' and recognises that the government is often hindered by the lack of co-operation from source countries and problems obtaining adequate documentation in effecting removals."

She agreed that the targets had been unrealistic.

"I agree with the committee on this, there's no point having targets that aren't realistic and at that point in time it was not realistic," said Hughes.

But the minister maintained that the government is getting to grips with immigration issues, since "warning bells" were sounded by race riots in some northern cities in 2001.

"It's actually precisely because we foresaw some of the problems of community relations in Britain and that we took the decision that we had to act and start to act then... to separate the asylum system from migration generally to make sure that we didn't have people using the asylum system to come here and work," she told the BBC.

Britain also now has "much more secure" border controls with France the minister claimed.

The Refugee Council said the committee's work was a "compelling contribution" to the arguments that have flared in recent years.

Acting chief executive Margaret Lally said: "We very much welcome this report from this influential committee, which we believe to be one of the most compelling contributions to the asylum debate in recent years.

"We look forward to the government implementing the committee's recommendations without delay."

The Conservatives announced they have set up a commission to take an in-depth look at the future of asylum policy.

Shadow home secretary Oliver Letwin said he has asked MEP Timothy Kirkhope to chair the commission as part of the party's "ongoing review" of asylum.

Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Simon Hughes claimed the current problems stemmed from a system does not work well.

"The asylum detention and removal process is a long, drawn out and distressing experience for many who go through it," he said.

"The difficulties in removing failed asylum seekers have as much to do with the inefficiency of the Home Office as with any lack of co-operation by asylum seekers.

"Providing early and honest advice to people about their prospects for asylum or economic migration goes a long way towards minimising the problems."

Committee member and Conservative former Home Office minister Ann Widdecombe told the BBC that the report's consensual nature was indicative of the depth of the crisis.

"This was a cross-party group who have condemned the totally unrealistic setting of targets - talking about 30,000 removals, which they were never able to explain and must have known right from the start was impossible - trumpeting high-sounding targets but actually achieving very little," she said.

"I believe, until you move to a situation whereby you detain all new applicants in secure reception centres, so you know where they are, we will have this problem, because in this country we have no identity cards and it is very easy to disappear."

The committee will now begin a new inquiry into the asylum system, concentrating on the applications process.

Published: Thu, 8 May 2003 01:00:00 GMT+01
Author: Chris Smith

"We are dealing with human beings, not numbers and they should be treated accordingly" - Mullin