|
Watchdog warns on care for asylum seekers
 |
| Anne Owers |
Five new government centres for asylum seekers should improve their standards of care and service, the prisons watchdog has said.
Anne Owers, the chief inspector of prisons, said that conditions for the "vulnerable group of people in their care" often fell short of what was required.
New reports examined four removal centres - Tinsley House, Campsfield House, Haslar and Lindholme - and a reception centre at Oakington.
Assessing the experience of detainees as well as the views of staff and the direct observation of inspectors, the reports highlighted "some good practice and relationships within centres, as well as some common areas of weakness".
"We found that the two Prison Service centres, in particular, were struggling with their new responsibilities under detention centre rules, and a great deal of work and staff training was needed in key areas," said Owers.
"There are also messages for the Immigration Service, which, in all but one centre, was not providing detainees with comprehensible and current information about their individual cases; and which must work with centre managers to ensure that detainees can be properly and humanely prepared for release, transfer or removal."
Research found that just 37 per cent of detainees in the centres felt safe, but this was linked to the insecurity of their position and the fact that they did not know what was going to happen to them.
The report also called for staff to be given more training and support in dealing with the specific needs of detainees, and the different national and ethnic groups from which they come.
"Detainees were given insufficient notice of further detention or removal, sometimes deliberately, and were often unable to contact families or representatives. Though this was designed to avoid self-harm or security problems, in practice it merely transferred them elsewhere; and made security and control problems at the point of departure more likely," the study warned.
Owers said that some of the recommendations had already been acted on, but said that "much more needs to be done if all centres are to be brought up to an acceptable standard".
Responding to the report, Home Office minister Beverley Hughes said the centres were essential to ensure effective immigration controls and the speedy removal of those who have unfounded asylum claims.
"We are committed to ensuring that detainees are treated with respect and decency, and have put in place the process for an independent inspection of immigration removal centres to ensure a transparent inspection regime to ensure this," she said.
The ministers said she would consider the recommendations but indicated they might not all be accepted.
"The inspectorate have made a number of detailed recommendations to which we will give careful consideration. However, a large proportion of the findings reflect only the comments of the detainees themselves.
"As people are generally unhappy about being detained and removed from the country, it is unsurprising that they express dissatisfaction with their situation," Hughes said.
The Children's Society highlighted the detention of refugee children in the centres.
It backed a call to avoid locking up children as much as possible and called the report's finding that children should not be detained for more than seven days "a step forward".
"But it is shocking that children are being locked up in removal centres at all and we urge the government to put a stop to this inhumane policy.
"Locking up children for one day is a day too long. They have broken no laws, have not been tried by any court and are often extremely vulnerable and distressed. Being treated like a criminal will have a serious impact on their physical and emotional health and well being," said a Children's Society statement.
But Hughes said that while she was "deeply sympathetic" to concerns about the detention of children, it was at times an "essential" practice.
"It is completely impractical to suggest a time limit - which would enable people to evade removal by lodging last minute and time-wasting appeals," the minister added.
|