Westminster Scotland Wales London Northern Ireland European Union Local
ePolitix.com

 
[ Advanced Search ]

Login | Contact | Terms | Accessibility

Parliament urged to improve tax scrutiny

Parliament should be doing more to scrutinise the government's tax policies, a leading think tank has said.

The Institute of Fiscal Studies said that with the British tax system becoming ever more complicated, the Commons should be tougher and more thorough in holding Gordon Brown's Treasury to account.

The report, by a working party of the IFS's tax law review committee, set out six key recommendations to improve the ways in which parliament deals with tax proposals and legislation.

These include the creation of a select committee on taxation and more time set aside for MPs to debate the pre-Budget report.

Chaired by Sir Alan Budd, a former chief economic adviser to the Treasury, the working party called on MPs to improve the accountability, transparency and simplicity of parliaments' tax changing powers.

Parliament must involve itself at an earlier stage in the process of examining the government's tax proposals and legislation, the committee said.

The report builds on the recommendations of the House of Commons' modernisation select committee, which has also urged improved scrutiny of the way economic policy decisions are pushed through parliament.

The annual Finance Act collates all tax changes required by the chancellor that cannot be covered by statutory instruments.

It rarely faces any amendments or difficulty in its passage through parliament.

Another recommendation in the report was for parliamentary pre-legislative scrutiny of tax proposals "once they have moved beyond the drawing board and government has decided to implement them".

There should also be changes to ensure that parliament is always given "the time and the means to consider the tax proposals" that the government intends in to ask MPs to endorse in Finance Act.

Published: Thu, 20 Mar 2003 11:30:00 GMT+00
Author: Daniel Forman

» STAKEHOLDER LINKS

Anti Social Behaviour Unit
APACS
Association of Accounting Technicians - Briefings and responses
Association of Chartered Certified Accountants - Business Issues
Atos Origin
Basic Skills Agency
BG Group - Welcome
BNTL
BUPA - Submissions, Articles & Publications
Charities Aid Foundation - Welcome
Charity Commission - A – Z of key issues
Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development
CLIC
Construction Products Association
Council of Heads of Medical Schools'
Council of Mortgage Lenders
Country Land and Business Association - Current Policy Issues
Countryside Agency
Crossrail
Depression Alliance
Disabilities Trust
EDS - UK Government
Electrical Contractors Association - Key Issues
Engineering and Technology Board
Federation of Small Businesses - ePolitix Consultations
Finance & Leasing Association
Forum of Private Business
General Teaching Council
Help the Aged - Policy & Campaigning
Homeless Link
IEE
IFAW - UK Campaigns
Institute of Directors - ePolitix Consultations
Insulin Dependent Diabetes Trust
INTERPAL
Joseph Rowntree Foundation - Index
Local Government Information Unit
Medical Research Council
NASUWT
National Office of Animal Health
National Savings and Investments - Our story
National Union of Teachers - Manifesto
NHS Confederation
NMC
Princes Trust
Professional Association of Teachers
Rio Tinto Plc
RNIB - Election Manifesto 2005
Royal British Legion - Manifesto
Royal College of Physicians
SANE - Mental Health Issues
SCOP
Secondary Heads Association
Stagecoach Group
Stroke Association
Traditional Housing Bureau
Visual Arts and Galleries Association